【讨论】梅威瑟是有史以来最被高估的拳手么？

闲着没事

Is Mayweather the most OVERRATED fighter of all time?
09-12-2022, 06:27 PM
I mean let’s be honest with ourselves. His resume is absolutely garbage. All his big wins are over big names who were old and on their way out the door. Oscar, Mosley, Cotto, Pacquaio were all shells of themselves. 0 credit there. He fought Judah coming off a loss rather than the guy who beat Judah. Made Canelo fight 16 pounds below his current weight. He lost twice clearly, Madaina 1 and Castillo 1. He ducked prime Margarito, Williams, Winky, Pac. His best wins are Hatton and Corrales. He made Hatton jump up a weight class. Corrales spent training camp knowing he was going to prison after the fight. Mentally he had to be off. You just can’t compare mayweather to the all time greats. People who fought legitimate threats, and weren’t always sure of victory.

我们诚实面对自己；猴子的简历完全是垃圾。他所有的大赛打的都是那些年事已高，即将退役的大牌。奥斯卡，莫斯利，库托，帕奎奥都是空壳，过了巅峰期。点数落后的情况下阴了尤达赫。击败了体重比现在低了16磅的牛瓦。明显的输了两场-卡斯蒂洛和迈达纳。躲避马加里托，威廉姆斯。

最好的胜利是击败哈顿和克拉莱斯，但哈顿是被他提上来一个级别，克拉莱斯备战时候就知道自己赛后要进监狱。

我们不能把猴子和那些伟大的拳手相比，因为他遇到强敌打的都是踉踉跄跄。。。。。。。。。

---------------------------------------------------------------------
以上是boxingscene论坛的一个帖子，大概翻译了一下发现；老外的拳迷拳识匮乏，水平有点差。。。我随便补一条，把马奎兹拽上来两个级别，自己还超重

暗香浮动

照这样玩下去拳坛上就没一个像样的，全是垃圾。

功夫流

不能说无敌的存在，顶级拳手可以做，全胜的战绩靠裁判和挑选手！所以，没必要神话猴子

Gigiguang

感觉你是个拳盲

缘起缘落皆由心

威瑟被高估是肯定的，至于是不是有史以来最被高估的拳手就见仁见智。

雪谷

老臧正在满头大汗的狂奔而来。

吉普赛国王

额，这些理由都好低级。。。打莫斯利和豁牙就是欺负老人...打比自己小两岁的帕奎奥就是空壳不在巅峰期...赢了下一代的阿瓦就是欺负别人还年轻......击败过上个时代的p4p之王，击败过同时代的p4p之王，也击败过下个时代的p4p之王，你说为什么幸运女神总站在梅威瑟身后。

侃侃

只能说威瑟的智商和拳商是很高的

帕元帅

拳拳帝国之心

威瑟有点本事，技术上，算顶尖了。

技巧顶尖 + 绝对精明 + 投机取巧 + 裁判偏袒 + 巧妙包装 + 该打就打 + 不行就跑 = 威瑟